Disclaimer: I am not a Lawyer nor am I offering legal advice. I am only giving my honest opinions using court documents and statutes to reason.
I conducted an extensive analysis of the defamation lawsuit involving notable journalist Taylor Lorenz from the Washington Post, formerly from the New York Times, and Ariadna Jacob. Recently, a motion to dismiss was filed, accompanied by a letter from Taylor Lorenz and a response letter from Ari Jacob. I examined the cited legal precedents mentioned in an attempt to shed light on their respective arguments and provided insights on potential outcomes from the presiding judge.
To provide some context, according to the New York Times, Ariadna Jacob, the individual credited with discovering TikTok stars such as Addison Rae and Charli and Dixie D’Amelio, has accused technology journalist Taylor Lorenz and the New York Times of publishing a defamatory article that allegedly caused harm to her business. This case is notable due to the numerous defamatory statements detailed in Ariadna Jacob’s legal documents, comprising a total of 14 allegations. These include claims of leaked explicit content, operating without a license, and unauthorized filming of minors, among others. By examining these statements in conjunction with the article in question, we aim to comprehend the complete context of the case.
Flood, B (2021) Fox News: Entrepreneur Files 6.8 million dollar lawsuit vs. NY times [Article]
Jacob, A (2020) “Gary Vee Zoom + Influences TikTok Creators and Friends” [Youtube Channel: Ariadna Jacobs]
Jacob, A (2022) “GaryVee offers talent a Super Bowl commercial” [Youtube Channel: Ariadna Jacobs]
Lorenz, T (2020) “NY Times: Trying To Make It Big Online? Getting Signed Isn’t Everything” [Article]
Siu, A (2021) “TikTok Talent Agent Ariadna Jacob Sues NY Times, Reporter Taylor Lorenz for Defamation (Exclusive)” [Article]
Documents
Adam Cohen Declaration (PDF) [Online]
Kyle Offerece Declaration (PDF) [Online]
Second Amended Complaint by Ariadna Jacob (PDF), 2022 [Online]
Motion To Dismiss ORDER by Judge Ramos (PDF), 2022 [Online]
CASES CITED IN VIDEO ANALYSIS:
Celle vs. Filipino Reporter Enterprises (2000) [Online]